“Pie was on my ‘wish list’ for the bakery for years! I’m so proud of my team in the kitchen for testing, tasting, rolling, and baking these yummy beauties! ”
ALL OF OUR PIE CRUSTS ARE MADE WITH LINDLEY MILLS ORGANIC UNBLEACHED PASTRY FLOUR.
Ingredient notes: ( * ) indicates one of our special partners! ( eggs, milk, flours, extracts, dairy, pecans, produce )
For more details, see OUR PARTNERS page.
Banana Pudding
4.95 individual bowl; Large bowl with 10 servings $45
( We kindly request a few days notice on the large bowl. )
We cook our custard with Ward’s local, free-range eggs, Homeland Creamery’s fresh organic milk & pure vanilla. We then mix in a secret ingredient ( ask our staff if you really must know! ) and organic bananas and tuck organic cookie crumbles inside!
Sweet Potato Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Made with organic sweet potatoes from Faucette Farms and just the right amount of spice. This is sure to become a family favorite!
( Seasonal - Fall & early Winter )
Cherry Pie
6.95 per slice / 45 whole
We all love cherry pie … and this one brims with both tart red and dark sweet cherries with a delicate oat crumble topping.
Chocolate Chess Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
This is a chocolate lover’s dream pie! A chess pie always contains flour, butter, sugar and eggs for a dense, rich flavor. Our chocolate chess is made with Felchlin Swiss chocolate, Ward’s free range eggs, and Cook’s pure vanilla.
Ingredients: Filling: Felchlin chocolate, butter, sugar, local free range eggs, salt, vanilla*; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
Coconut Custard Pie
6.95 per slice / 42 whole
This pie dates back to 1893! Ours is very buttery and laden with coconut that rises to the top as it bakes! Immensely satisfying.
Ingredients: Filling: butter, sugar, salt, local free range eggs*, vanilla*, vinegar, coconut; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
Lemon Buttermilk Chess Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
A delicate custard pie made from Homeland Creamery buttermilk, organic lemon juice, Ward's free range eggs, and Cook's pure vanilla.
Ingredients: Filling: butter, sugar, organic unbleached flour*, salt, local milk*, local free range eggs*, vanilla*, organic lemon juice and zest; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
Chocolate Cream Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Our favorite chocolate cream pie in the world! ( Another of Etta Lea Pope’s almost-famous recipes! ) We cook the chocolate filling on our stovetop and pile it thickly into our crust. Once chilled it gets a high pile of freshly whipped cream from Homeland Creamery! Divine.
Ingredients: Filling: sugar, Hershey’s cocoa powder, flour, salt, local milk*, local free range eggs*, butter, vanilla*; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water; Whipped cream & Garnish: powdered sugar, cream cheese, local heavy cream*, grated chocolate
Coconut Cream Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Another staff favorite! The filling is so thick and satisfying! Full of flavor and texture. You must try this pie if you like coconut! Piled high with our amazing whipped cream from Homeland Creamery.
Ingredients: Filling: sugar, cornstarch, salt, local milk*, Jade mountain coconut milk, local free range eggs*, vanilla*, butter, shredded coconut; Whipped Cream & Garnish: powdered sugar, local heavy cream*, toasted coconut
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
6.95 per slice / 45 whole
Freshly roasted pecans baked into a decadent mixture of chocolate and brown sugar with a splash of Knob Creek Bourbon! A pie that is just full of flavor & texture and is so perfect for the winter months!
Ingredients: Filling: butter, local free range eggs*, Knob Creek bourbon, vanilla*, light corn syrup, brown sugar, sugar, organic unbleached flour*, salt, North Carolina pecans*, Ghirardelli chocolate chips; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
( Seasonal - Fall & Winter )
Key Lime Pie!
7.50 per slice / 63 whole
Featuring our signature “Aggression Cookie” crust with organic oats. Made the classic way with Nellie & Joe's Key Lime juice, local free-range eggs, and topped with fresh whipped cream from Homeland Creamery and a bit of organic lime zest!
Ingredients: Filling: Nellie and Joe’s key lime juice, local free range eggs*, evaporated milk; Crust: butter, brown sugar, vanilla*, salt, baking soda, organic unbleached flour*, organic oats; Whipped Cream & Garnish: powdered sugar, cream cheese, local heavy cream*, organic lime zest
Pecan Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Filled with freshly roasted pecans! We nestle them in a warm mixture of Homeland Creamery heavy cream, Ward’s free-range eggs, brown sugar and butter. It’s our favorite pecan pie ever!
Ingredients: Filling: butter, local heavy cream, local free range eggs, sugar, brown sugar, organic unbleached flour, salt, light corn syrup, North Carolina pecans*; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
Peach Pie
6.95 per slice / 45 whole
Featuring “Contender” local peaches from Harman Farms! This is a very limited run … so catch a slice of it while it’s here!
( Seasonal )
Summer Strawberry Pie
6.95 per slice / 45 whole
Our newest pie! We fill our flaky crust with an indulgent sweetened cream cheese on the bottom and top it with a juicy berry glaze. Whipped cream is optional, so let us know if you’d like some on yours!
( Seasonal )
Pumpkin Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Silky smooth in texture and spiced just right with cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves and ginger.
Ingredients: Filling: evaporated milk, local free range eggs*, pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, ginger, salt, brown sugar; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
( Seasonal - Begins October 21st! )
Banana Cream Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Light and simple custard with freshly sliced bananas tucked on the bottom. Piled high with our amazing whipped cream from Homeland Creamery.
( Seasonal - available through mid-May )
Lemon Meringue Pie
6.25 per slice / 42 whole
Such a classic! Our filling is made with freshly-squeezed organic lemons, local free-range eggs, pure butter and local milk!
Ingredients: Filling: sugar, cornstarch, salt, local milk*, organic lemon juice, local free range eggs*, butter; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water; Meringue: local egg whites*, cream of tartar, sugar
( Seasonal - Spring)
Blueberry Pie
6.95 per slice / 45 whole
This pie features local blueberries from Possibility Farms and is the perfect end to a summer day! These blueberries are grown using organic methods. We simply mix them with the juice and zest from organic lemons and a bit of sugar, salt, cornstarch, and butter. Voila! We know you will love it!
Ingredients: Filling: sugar, cornstarch, salt, organic lemon zest, local blueberries*, butter; Crust: butter, organic unbleached flour*, sugar, salt, vinegar, water
( Seasonal - Memorial Day through Labor Day )